GPM Investments | AI Transformation Index

GPM Investments is a structurally durable physical-asset business whose moat is its ~3,200-location fuel and convenience network — the kind of infrastructu...

GPM InvestmentsRetail (Specialty Retail)Harvest Partners

Overview

GPM Investments operates approximately 3,200 convenience store and fuel station locations across 33 states, generating revenue through fuel sales, in-store merchandise, foodservice/QSR franchises, wholesale fuel supply to dealers, and fleet fueling cardlock locations.

Executive Summary

GPM Investments is a structurally durable physical-asset business whose moat is its ~3,200-location fuel and convenience network — the kind of infrastructure that AI cannot disrupt because the customer outcome requires physical delivery at a fixed geographic location. The AI opportunity, however, is commensurately modest: with the vast majority of costs and value creation tied to physical operations, AI's reach is limited to pricing optimization, inventory management, and loyalty personalization — meaningful but incremental improvements, not a transformational story. For a PE investor, GPM is an attractive hold on durability grounds but is not a high-conviction AI transformation opportunity; the value creation thesis is physical network expansion and operational excellence, not AI-driven step-change.

Durability

How resilient is this business against AI disruption?

FactorValue

Market Substitutability

8

Profit Pool Migration

7

Barrier to Entry

8

Disintermediation Exposure

8

Switching Costs

6
Total74.0
×

Opportunity

How big a deal is AI for this business?

FactorValue

AI Applicability

4

Improvement Magnitude

5

Transformation Upside

3

Domain Intelligence Amplification

3
Total37.5

52.7

Ciridae AI Score

Durability Rationale

GPM's durability is fundamentally anchored in its irreplaceable physical network — you cannot replace a fuel pump or a convenience store with software, and the ~3,200-location footprint across 33 states represents a capital-intensive, permit-heavy, geographically distributed asset base that no AI-native entrant can replicate. The primary structural risks to this view are long-run EV adoption compressing fuel volumes and potential margin pressure at the payment layer from fintech intermediaries, but neither is an AI disruption thesis — they are infrastructure and distribution theses operating on decade-plus timelines. Consumer switching costs are moderate, which tempers the picture, but the physical lock-in of the network itself is the dominant durability driver.

Opportunity Rationale

The AI opportunity for GPM is real but bounded by the fundamental nature of the business — most of what GPM does is physical, and AI cannot compress fuel dispensing, store staffing, or food preparation the way it can compress cognitive labor. The tractable opportunity lies in demand forecasting, dynamic pricing, loyalty personalization, and back-office logistics optimization — areas where AI can deliver meaningful unit-economic improvements but not the order-of-magnitude transformation available to businesses built on cognitive labor. GPM is not the sweet spot for PE-relevant AI catalysis; it lacks the large manual knowledge workforce where AI delivers the biggest step-change.

Key Risks

Long-run EV adoption accelerates faster than expected, compressing fuel volumes which represent the primary traffic driver for in-store merchandise — this is the primary structural risk to durability, even though it is not an AI thesis.

The AI opportunity may be overstated even at the incremental level if competitors (Sheetz, GetGo, larger chains with more sophisticated tech teams) implement pricing and loyalty AI faster, neutralizing any first-mover benefit and meaning the opportunity is commoditized before it is captured.

Company Overview

HeadquartersRichmond, Virginia, United States
Products / Services
Convenience store merchandise, fuel sales, quick-service restaurant franchises, loyalty programs, prepaid products, Western Union kiosks, RedBox rentals
Deal Partners
Jay HegenbartSean Murphy

PE / Ownership History

EventDetails
Harvest Partners announced promotions of senior leaders including Scott Hopson and Erik Weil, but no specific deal leadership for GPM Investments was noted.
January 20, 2026
GPM Investments engaged in multiple acquisitions, primarily funded by Oak Street Real Estate Capital, including assets from Quarles Petroleum Inc., Transit Energy Group, Pride Convenience Holdings LLC, and WTG Fuels Holdings LLC.
Various in 2022
Harvest Partners Structured Capital Fund (SCF) acquired a $62.5 million minority ownership stake in GPM Investments, LLC. The deal was led by Jay Hegenbart and Sean Murphy, Senior Managing Director and Managing Director at Harvest Partners, respectively.
January 30, 2017

Executives

NameBackground
Arie Kotler
Chief Executive Officer (CEO)
Arie Kotler has been CEO and President of GPM Investments since September 2011 and April 2015 respectively. He has led the company through significant growth and acquisition phases, focusing on building a retail legacy and expanding store remodels and foodservice offerings. Prior roles are not publicly detailed, but he is recognized as a leading figure in convenience retail.
Mark King
Chief Financial Officer (CFO)
Mark King previously served as CFO at VPS Convenience Store Group and CC Intelligent Solutions. He was also Managing Director at Jacobs Capital, LLC. He holds an MBA from Duke University - The Fuqua School of Business and is based in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Andy Gammel
Executive Vice President of Operations
Andy Gammel has held senior operations roles at Empire Petroleum Partners, LLC, including Senior Vice President of Operations. He is educated at The University of Texas at Austin and is based in Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex.
Raymond Dalton
Chief Information Officer (CIO)
Raymond Dalton has held senior technology roles at Empire Petroleum Partners, LLC, including Senior Vice President, Technology and Services. He has extensive experience in data management and technology leadership, based in Richmond, Virginia.
Don Bassell
Executive Vice President at ARKO Corp / GPM Investments
Don Bassell was CFO of GPM Investments for 7 years and is now EVP at ARKO Corp., which owns 100% of GPM Investments. He has a background in accounting with education from Duke University, based in the Greater Richmond Region.